icScotland - Minister accused over abortion move
icScotland logo
icScotland News Sport icHomes
Search icScotland for:
Today's UK news
News  UK  Today's UK news  Article

Minister accused over abortion move

14:05, Oct 31 2012

 

A health minister has been accused of imposing her own personal beliefs on Government policy by deciding to ditch proposals to ban abortion clinics from offering advice to women seeking terminations.

Tory MP Nadine Dorries said it was a bizarre decision to scrap a consultation on plans which would prevent clinics run by Marie Stopes and the British Pregnancy Advisory Service from offering counselling to women at the same time as carrying out terminations.

Pro-life campaigners, including Ms Dorries, have argued that there is a conflict of interest as many pregnant women who seek advice from clinics go on to have abortions.

Instead, they argue, ministers should have rubber-stamped proposals forcing women to take advice from counselling services separate from the clinic they had chosen to carry out their abortion.

Following Wednesday's announcement by Health Minister Anna Soubry that the Government would no longer even contemplate the plans, Ms Dorries said: "This is quite bizarre. What Anna Soubry has said today doesn't improve services for women.

"The Government has decided that it is not the right decision, and what makes it even more bizarre is that the British Medical Association voted to support the consultation.

"This announcement comes down to Anna Soubry's very personal belief on abortion. She is as pro-choice as many Labour women MPs. Jeremy Hunt (the Health Secretary) believes in a 12-week limit but he is not trying to push his agenda on women because he acknowledges it is his personal belief. Anna Soubry has a personal belief. What she has done is try to impose her personal belief on her role and that is out of order."

During a debate in Westminster Hall earlier, Ms Soubry said she had decided to call off the consultation because the Government had no intention of changing the law, adding that if ministers were to plough on regardless it would be an "otiose exercise".

The minister added: "There is other work we should be doing on counselling. I take the view that this is not the primary function we should be addressing and that is why I have taken the decision that I have." Abortions are allowed in the UK under certain circumstances until an unborn baby has reached 24 weeks.

Ms Dorries said that the legal limit should be reduced to 20 weeks as it was possible to save a premature baby born at 22 or 23 weeks. It could not be right that doctors tried to save some babies while at the same time ending the lives of others, she said. She added that many voters wanted to see a change in the law and it could end up costing some MPs in marginal seats at the next general election if they continue to block reforms to the way abortions are carried out.

 
Duchess opts for a natural birth
Police urged to probe 'cover-up'
Deputy Speaker denies sex claims
Health cover-up staff face action
Karzai threat to Taliban peace deal
Brady still psychotic, says doctor
Family delight at Iraq court ruling
Mail staff vote for rivals' boycott
Reckless bankers could face jail
Starr 'hopes name will be cleared'
Cities vying for culture spotlight
No 10 raps 'appalling' CQC cover-up
Soldiers' families win claims fight
More allegations for Deputy Speaker
Karzai threat to Afghan peace talks
MP angry at death hospital cover-up
UK could enjoy hottest day of year
Taliban behind US soldier deaths
Jail reckless bankers, says report
Hospital care cover-up 'shocking'
Top Top

Back Back

E-mail this article to a friend

Printable VersionPrintable version

 
News  UK  Today's UK news  Article
 


Copyright and Trade Mark Notice
© owned by or licensed to Scottish & Universal Newspapers Limited 2013.
icScotland™ is a trade mark of Scottish & Universal Newspapers Limited.
Please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Statement before using this site.

 
Advertisements
 
Jobs in Scotland: