icScotland - Fiddled death rates claim rejected
icScotland logo
icScotland News Sport icHomes
Search icScotland for:
Today's UK news
News  UK  Today's UK news  Article

Fiddled death rates claim rejected

14:05, Mar 2 2013

 

An NHS Trust has rejected claims that it fiddled its death rate figures, describing the allegations as an "outrageous slur" on its workforce.

The Royal Wolverhampton NHS Trust said independently-verified evidence "categorically disproved" the claims made by one of its own employees, Sandra Haynes-Kirkbright.

Mrs Haynes-Kirkbright, a data recorder who is facing disciplinary action after an investigation into her management practices, told the Daily Mail she was "headhunted" by the Trust and asked to "fix" its mortality figures.

Claiming that "every rule in the book" was broken to try to improve mortality rates, Mrs Haynes-Kirkbright also alleged that she was suspended from her post as a senior "health coder" after refusing to take part in a cover-up.

Responding to the allegations, the Trust's chief executive, David Loughton, said: "We categorically deny all the allegations and have provided detailed evidence to the Daily Mail to support our position that the suggestion of any wrong-doing is simply not true.

"Improvements in the hospital's mortality rates have been audited and independently verified. We are proud of the quality of care we offer and our commitment to putting our patients first at all time. These allegations are an outrageous slur on the hard-working clinical and support staff who provide high quality services to the people of Wolverhampton and surrounding areas."

In a statement addressing each allegation in detail, the Trust said a marked improvement in mortality rates between 2010 and 2012 had been independently verified by the Doctor Foster organisation, which provides information on health and social care services.

The statement said: "The Trust's improvement in (the three different methods of measuring mortality rates) in 2011/12 is as a result of the reduction in the actual number of people that died in the hospital Compared to 2010/11, there were 200 fewer deaths in 2011/12."

Mrs Haynes-Kirkbright was suspended after allegations of bullying, harassment, persistent swearing and unprofessional behaviour were made against her by colleagues through their union in April last year. An investigation into the claims found a case to answer in respect of all allegations raised, and Mrs Haynes-Kirkbright was informed in January that she will face a disciplinary hearing.

In her response to the allegations made against her, submitted in July last year, Mrs Haynes-Kirkbright is known to have raised "coding issues" which were dealt with in a separate investigation under the Trust's whistle-blowing policy. The inquiry, led by the Trust's medical director, concluded in November after finding no evidence to support the allegations raised.

 
Act on tax avoidance, urges Cameron
Better pay 'means bigger classes'
Tornado survivors search nears end
PM faces gay marriage Bill backlash
55 beaches meet tough new standards
£100bn 'lost through tax avoidance'
'Failures' in tax fraud crackdown
102 free school proposals approved
Police force to sell unused £11m HQ
'Alarming rate' of wildlife decline
Afghan interpreters can come to UK
Food hygiene 'a postcode lottery'
Clegg dismisses coalition break-up
Gay marriage plan backed by MPs
Tornado rescue search 'almost over'
Seven UK child soldiers in Mid East
Gay marriage Bill clears Commons
Microsoft reveals Xbox One console
Nicholson set to retire with £1.9m
Patients 'harmed' by 111 service
Top Top

Back Back

E-mail this article to a friend

Printable VersionPrintable version

 
News  UK  Today's UK news  Article
 


Copyright and Trade Mark Notice
© owned by or licensed to Scottish & Universal Newspapers Limited 2013.
icScotland™ is a trade mark of Scottish & Universal Newspapers Limited.
Please read our Terms and Conditions and Privacy Statement before using this site.

 
Advertisements
 
Jobs in Scotland: